Ancient Scripture scrolls of the Bible canon gathered around the cross within the worshipping Church

Who Decided Which Books Are in the Bible?

Who decided the books of the Bible? No single emperor invented the canon; the early Church gradually recognised the writings received as apostolic Scripture in worship, teaching and communion.

Quick Answer

The biblical canon emerged through centuries of Jewish and Christian reception. Bishops and councils did not make inspired books inspired. They discerned and formally named the texts the Church had received as normative. Catholics recognise 46 Old Testament books and 27 New Testament books, for 73 in total.

Understand Scripture within the Church through Faith + Reason.

What Is the Deposit of Faith?

The deposit of faith is the whole of divine revelation, contained in Sacred Scripture and Sacred Tradition, that Christ entrusted to the apostles and the Church to guard and hand on. Saint Paul tells Timothy to guard what has been entrusted to him (1 Timothy 6:20; 2 Timothy 1:14).

The canon of the Bible belongs inside the deposit of faith. The Church recognised the books she had received as Scripture, and her teaching office serves the word of God rather than standing above it (Dei Verbum, paragraph 10; Catechism, paragraphs 84 to 86). Source: Second Vatican Council, Dei Verbum.

What Does “Canon” Mean?

Canon means a rule or standard. The biblical canon is the collection of books received by the Church as inspired Scripture and authoritative for faith.

Individual books were written in different periods and places. Recognition was therefore historical, communal and sometimes disputed. A table of contents did not arrive with the apostles.

Did Constantine or the Council of Nicaea Choose the Bible?

No. The Council of Nicaea in 325 addressed the divinity of Christ and other Church matters, not a secret vote that created the biblical canon. Constantine commissioned copies of Scripture, but he did not decide which books were inspired.

Canon lists and Christian use existed before Nicaea. The Muratorian Fragment, Origen and other early witnesses show broad agreement on many New Testament books alongside questions about a smaller number.

How Did the Church Discern the New Testament?

The Church considered apostolic origin or connection, consistency with the apostolic rule of faith, widespread reception and use in worship. These were not mechanical tests applied by isolated scholars. They described how the Church recognised the voice of the apostolic witness.

The four Gospels and most Pauline letters were accepted early. Hebrews, James, 2 Peter, 2 and 3 John, Jude and Revelation were disputed in some regions before the canon stabilised.

Why Does the Catholic Old Testament Have 46 Books?

Early Christians commonly used Greek Jewish Scriptures that included books Catholics call deuterocanonical, such as Wisdom, Sirach, Tobit, Judith and 1 and 2 Maccabees. These texts appear in early Christian worship and theology.

During the Reformation, Protestants placed these books outside the Old Testament canon, generally following a narrower Hebrew collection. Catholic and Orthodox traditions retained the wider inheritance, though Orthodox lists vary.

When Was the Canon Formally Defined?

Regional councils at Hippo and Carthage in the late fourth century listed the books corresponding to the Catholic canon, and Pope Innocent I gave a similar list in 405. The Council of Trent solemnly defined the canon in 1546 amid Reformation disputes.

These formal acts did not mean the Church lacked Scripture until those dates. Definition often becomes most explicit when an established inheritance is contested.

Myth and History

Popular claimHistorical picture
Constantine created the BibleRecognition of these books predates and outlasts his reign
Nicaea voted books in and outNicaea did not establish the canon
One council made books inspiredCouncils recognised texts received in the Church
Every book was accepted immediatelySeveral books remained disputed regionally
The Catholic Church added seven booksReformers adopted a narrower Old Testament collection

Why the Canon Matters to Me

The history keeps Scripture from becoming a book detached from the community that received it. I meet the Bible as the inspired word of God handed on in the Church, centred on Jesus Christ and proclaimed in worship. Historical complexity does not weaken that gift; it shows how patiently it was received.

Who This Explanation Is For

This is for Catholics answering conspiracy claims, Christians comparing biblical traditions and readers wondering why Bibles contain different numbers of books.

Who This Explanation Is Not For

It is not a claim that every detail of this history was simple, unanimous or settled by one document.

How to Investigate a Canon Claim

1. Ask which century and source the claim concerns.

2. Distinguish local use from universal reception.

3. Check an early canon list directly.

4. Separate inspiration from later formal definition.

5. Compare Catholic, Protestant and Orthodox Old Testament lists accurately.

Truths Worth Remembering

The Church recognised the canon; she did not create inspiration.

Nicaea did not secretly choose the books of the Bible.

Some boundaries required centuries of discernment.

Scripture was received within worship centred on Jesus Christ.

Read the Bible within its living history through Faith + Reason.

Frequently Asked Questions

How many books are in the Catholic Bible?

There are 73: 46 in the Old Testament and 27 in the New Testament.

Did the Council of Nicaea decide the canon?

No. Its surviving records and historical purpose concern chiefly the Arian controversy and Church discipline, not a vote on the books of Scripture.

What are the deuterocanonical books?

They are Old Testament books and additions received as Scripture by Catholics but commonly placed in the Apocrypha or omitted from Protestant Bibles.

Did Catholics add books at Trent?

No. Trent solemnly defined a canon long used in the Church when that inheritance was challenged during the Reformation.

Why trust the Church’s discernment?

Christ entrusted the apostolic faith to a visible community guided by the Holy Spirit. The same Church that proclaimed the Gospel preserved and recognised its normative writings.

What To Do Next

Compare Athanasius’s Festal Letter 39 with the Council of Trent’s canon. Note both agreement and historical development. Then read Luke 24 and observe how Jesus, the Scriptures and apostolic witness belong together.

Explore reasonable Catholic Christianity through Faith + Reason.

About Crom Salvatera

Crom Salvatera, a husband and father trying to live his faith, has a Bible on his desk and plenty of questions about how it came together. He is grateful to the Church that handed it on. Scripture. Philosophy. Christ.

References

Vatican Council II. (1965). Dei Verbum, paragraphs 11–13

Council of Trent. (1546). Decree Concerning the Canonical Scriptures

Athanasius of Alexandria. (367). Festal Letter 39

Gallagher, E. L., and Meade, J. D. (2017). The Biblical Canon Lists from Early Christianity. Oxford University Press

Similar Posts